“1 JOHN 5:16”

“If any man see his brother sin a sin which is not unto death, he shall ask, and he shall give him life for them that sin not unto death. There is a sin unto death:

 I do not say that he shall pray for it.” (1 John 5:16) 

Dear Reader, why couldn’t John just put it beyond all doubt and say either …

“I do say that he shall not pray for it”
or
“I do say that he shall pray for it.” 

I mean that would make it crystal clear wouldn’t it?

But he doesn’t does he? No. He comes across as obscure and unsure … and maybe deliberately as well.

I believe that John is saying “I’ll leave it up to you … you can pray for it or not.”

And Dear Reader, I believe this is where the meaning lies.

We must remember that we follow Paul, and how he would handle things, and what he would say on any matter … not John … or James … or Peter.

All things in the Bible are not equal.  

Paul says that we are to follow Paul as he follows Christ

(1 Corinthians 4:16;11:1; Philippians 3:17).

Indeed Peter does not have the understanding of Paul
(2 Peter 3:16).

And James has confused many a scholar with the word ‘justified’ (James 2:21;James 2: 24;James 2: 25.)

Dear Reader, there is only one unforgiveable sin, and that is to die unsaved.

Indeed many of us personally know of friends and family that we continue to pray for, and  their salvation.

But at the present moment, this is their sin unto death.

Would John be saying “Don’t continue to pray for their salvation as God has made them this way (1 John 5:10)?”

I think not, as Paul says to pray without ceasing and to let your requests be made known unto God
(1Thessalonians 5:17; Philippians 4:6)
; and indeed Samuel under the Old Testament  (1 Samuel 12:23).

Dear Reader, you can request anything you like from God, and if it be his will, he will grant it.

You can pray and request God for Putin’s or Xi Jinping’s salvation … even though they seem to be on the course of everlasting burnings of unbelief … a sin unto death.

There came a point in time when after Pharoah had hardened his heart against God, that God irrevocably made sure that that Pharoah’s heart remained hardened.

I mean Moses had just spent 40 years in the desert … alone with God … and knew, that he knew, that he knew that praying for Pharoah’s change of heart was not God’s will.

Dear Reader, would you claim that same surety of God’s decision to harden someone’s heart?

I’m sure God has hardened some people’s hearts, but I wouldn’t be so arrogant to guess … how about you?

I’ve read where people have prayed for a person’s salvation for forty years … before they got saved.

I’m sure some might have given up … you know … “It’s no use praying for them anymore!”

But in my humble opinion, err on the side of caution … do not set yourself up as God … as judge, jury and executioner … in deciding who you will pray … or not pray for … as having a sin unto death.

Make sense?

It is God’s will that all be saved come to the knowledge of the truth (1 Timothy 2:4).

Let me leave you with this … in paraphrasing John, I believe he is saying the following …

 “I am not saying you shall pray for it, and I’m not saying you shall not pray for it. I’ll leave it up to you.”

Harley Hitchcock
August 2026

This website’s front page is:
www.AustralianBibleMinistries.com


PRAY FOR THE PEACE OF JERUSALEM

“Pray FOR the peace of Jerusalem …”
(Psalm 122:6)



 “IS THIS YOU …?



I’M OFF TO VALHALLA WHEN I DIE …
I’M A VIKING!



 “HAVE PEOPLE GONE TO HELL  MISUNDERSTANDING THE 4TH VERSE OF
 THE ROMANS ROAD … THE TEN-NINE”  VERSE?





CONTACT US

Australian Bible Ministries, PO Box 5058, Mt. Gravatt East 4122 Qld, Australia
  www.AustralianBibleMinistries.com